Chokeholds, Gena & The Belly of Truth | John Cassavetes’ Darkest Day | Hollywood Mysteries #136

Chokeholds, Gena & The Belly of Truth | John Cassavetes' Darkest Day | Hollywood Mysteries #136

The man who redefined American cinema spent his final years racing against a clock only he could hear. In the summer of 1983, on a set that was simply his own house above Hollywood, John Cassavetes received a death sentence—and told no one.

He did not tell his wife, Gena Rowlands, who was playing the lead. He did not tell the crew, who watched in confusion as the director’s stomach swelled tight as a drum beneath his shirt while the rest of his frame seemed to shrink away. He did not tell anyone that doctors had given him six months to live.

Instead, he began rewriting the script every night, as if the ending of the movie was a door he had to reach before someone locked it forever.

The diagnosis was cirrhosis of the liver. The prognosis was terminal. Cassavetes, however, would not comply with the timeline.

He took the six months and stretched them into five and a half years, spending that borrowed time drinking, gambling, arguing with studios, and mounting one last play in a theater with fewer than seventy seats. Every take was a countdown, and he never once let on.

Born John Nicholas Cassavetes in New York City on December 9th, 1929, six weeks after the stock market crash, he arrived with timing that seemed to follow him around. His father, Nicholas, had emigrated from Larissa in Thessaly in 1908, building enough success to settle the family on Long Island. His mother, Katherine, was a Greek American from New York who would later appear in her son’s films playing bewildered old ladies with a naturalism no 𝒹𝓇𝒶𝓂𝒶 school could teach.

The Depression destroyed his father’s fortunes, forcing the family to retreat to Greece around 1932. John learned Greek as his first language and returned to America at age seven speaking no English. The future poet of American inarticulacy began his life in the United States unable to make himself understood, listening to a language he had to guess at the meaning of.

It was a training ground for the observational genius that would define his work.

Ray Carney, who spent eleven years compiling Cassavetes’ words into a book, observed that the director could learn more from an hour of watching faces in a restaurant than from a month in a library. That skill, honed from childhood necessity, became the foundation of his revolutionary approach to filmmaking.

His path to cinema was anything but direct. He bounced through several colleges, expelled from at least one for poor grades, before presenting himself at the American Academy of Dramatic Arts in Manhattan, graduating in 1950. “All I wanted was a job,” he said later.

It is not the origin story a legend usually gets, but it is the truth.

The apprenticeship was grim. He played stock theater in Providence, Rhode Island, and pounded New York pavements without an agent, which in that town is invisibility. The stories from those years are not charming.

They are the stories of a short man—he stood 5’7″—driven by an enormous surplus of energy with no good outlet.

He chained himself to a radiator at CBS to get a walk-on role. He faked an appendicitis attack in a receptionist’s office and refused to break character even when paramedics arrived. A casting director once turned him down claiming nobody would believe him as a murderer.

Cassavetes returned that afternoon with a gun and asked whether the man believed it now. The man wept in fear.

Half his friends concluded he was insane. The other half found that entering a bar with him became street theater and adored him for it. Both halves were right, and this split defined his way.

Then, in late 1953, the chaos found a target. He saw Gena Rowlands, a banker’s daughter from Wisconsin with cool manners and Carole Lombard poise, and reported to a friend on the spot that she was the girl he was going to marry. “I spotted this doll one day and pretended that I wanted to talk to her about a role, and that was it,” he said.

Rowlands described the identical moment with equal candor. “Saw it coming. I was a woman with a plan.

The only thing that could really stop me from succeeding was to fall in love.” Then she saw him and thought, “Oh, damn. Not this.

This is exactly what I don’t want.”

They married in March 1954, four months after meeting. It lasted thirty-five years until his death, and it was a war neither of them wanted to win.

Television saved him. The live 𝒹𝓇𝒶𝓂𝒶 boom was on, and Cassavetes, dark and coiled, was cast repeatedly as a troubled boy with a knife somewhere on him. He appeared in Danger, Kraft Television Theatre, Omnibus, and dozens of teleplays.

Films followed the same type: a killer in The Night Holds Terror, a switchblade delinquent in Crime in the Streets, and a drifter opposite Sidney Poitier in Edge of the City.

By 1957, critics compared him to Brando. What he did with the moment was start an acting workshop and fill it with people who did not fit in at all. “I put an ad in the New York Times,” he recalled.

“And I said, anybody who wants to come down to use the workshop to work on acting, come on down. And the next day the place was mobbed.”

They were, he noted gleefully, “all amateurs, pickpockets, lawyers, bankers, policemen, students, people off the street.” His pitch was not about technique but temperament. “Individual expression is the highest paying commodity,” he told a fan magazine.

“Who needs good looks when you’re an individual?”

One workshop exercise became a film. Shadows, shot on a borrowed 16mm camera on New York streets and in the apartment he shared with his wife, was funded by roughly $2,000 in small bills from insomniacs and cab drivers who heard him announce on late-night radio that he could make a better picture than the one he was promoting. Charles Mingus wrote music.

The budget reached about $40,000.

The film ended with a title card announcing it was an improvisation. It is one of the most famous sentences in American independent cinema. Cassavetes went to his grave having confessed it was not wholly true.

The first version, roughly an hour long, was unveiled at three free midnight screenings at the Paris Theater in November 1958. About 100 people came. The sound failed.

People walked out.

He estimated 90% of the audience hated it. His father told him it was a pure film but not a good one. Cassavetes decided it was “totally intellectual and therefore less than human” and went back to make it again.

The reworked Shadows won the Critics Award at Venice in 1960 and blew up.

The original print vanished, left on a New York subway train, sold in a box of unclaimed junk, and recovered forty years later in a Florida attic. Rowlands, who owns the rights, moved to stop its screening in 2004. The founding document of American independence remains locked away today.

Success in Europe produced a manifesto. “Hollywood is not failing, it has failed,” he wrote in Film Culture in 1959. Filmmaking could not survive without individual expression, and pictures made solely to please a producer’s idea of the public would please nobody and earn nothing.

NBC gave him his own series, Johnny Staccato, in which he played a jazz pianist who solved crimes. He took it for the money, which he badly needed. During Shadows, the Cassavetes owed the milkman more than a thousand dollars.

Rowlands was seven months pregnant. He took the last $300 set aside for the hospital and put it into the film, promising he would deliver the baby himself.

“You won’t be here,” his wife replied. “You’ll be shooting.”

Nicholas David Rowlands arrived on May 21st, 1959. Days later, his father left to start a television series. When Rowlands flew west to join him, she finally asked whether he intended to inquire about the baby.

“What baby?” he said.

Paramount offered him a contract after Shadows’ reviews. Too Late Blues, released in 1961, flopped. He took the lesson, which was not humility.

“I learned all the tricks,” he said. “Get a big office. Ask for everything.

Insist on it.”

Then came the moment that wrecked his career for four years. After a studio screening of A Child Is Waiting, which was recut against his wishes, Cassavetes demanded his name be removed. He shoved a producer against a wall.

The most repeated version has him punching Stanley Kramer and walking out. Nobody in Hollywood cared which version was accurate. He was an unmanageable maverick, and the town closed its door.

He survived by acting, which also paid for what he did next. Robert Aldrich cast him as Victor Franco in The Dirty Dozen in 1967, the insolent rat-faced killer who steals the picture from Lee Marvin. The performance brought an Oscar nomination.

Every dollar went into Faces, a savage film about a middle-aged couple who each spend a night with someone else.

The first cut ran six hours. Editing took thirty months. The final budget was around $275,000.

Lynn Carlin, playing the wife, was not a professional actress but a secretary. To produce the desolation he wanted, Cassavetes slapped her across the face seconds before a take and then shouted at her not to cry. She was nominated for an Academy Award.

Faces opened in 1968 to critical and commercial success. The pariah of 1963 was suddenly the most interesting director in America. He spent the intervening period taking money from pictures he did not respect to fund pictures nobody wanted.

The most famous was Rosemary’s Baby, in which he plays the actor husband who trades his wife’s womb for a career. He and Roman Polanski hated working together. Cassavetes took the check and put it into Faces.

His next film was born in a parking lot. He met Peter Falk at a Lakers game, then spotted Ben Gazzara across a lot at Universal. The money came from an aspiring Italian mogul who put up $1.

5 million and astonishingly ceded all artistic control. Husbands, released in 1970, follows three suburban men on a four-day bender after a friend’s funeral. It is, in places, pretty close to unwatchable, and this is by design.

Columbia cut eleven minutes from the prints without permission. Audiences walked out. Pauline Kael took it apart in The New Yorker.

Before any of that, Cassavetes, Falk, and Gazzara appeared on the Dick Cavett show to promote it and produced what Cavett still calls the worst show he ever did. They had been drinking. They wrestled on the floor, removed their shoes, and smelled each other’s feet.

Cavett walked off the set. The audience chanted for his return.

Afterwards, Cassavetes rounded on his friends and told them they had just unsold most of the tickets to the movie. He was right.

Universal inexplicably gave him Minnie and Moskowitz in 1971, a screwball romance between a lonely museum curator and a hairy parking attendant. It contains the most revealing anecdote of the marriage. Cassavetes did not tell his wife he would be playing Jim, her violent married lover, until moments before the scene was shot.

On camera, he hit her repeatedly until she was on the floor. The crew rushed to help her. Rowlands, furious at the ambush, pretended she was genuinely hurt to punish him.

She told the story afterwards with enjoyment, along with his response to her complaint. “Every man for himself.”

The masterpiece came out of a play he wrote for her. Rowlands said she wanted to appear in something about what contemporary women were up against. Cassavetes wrote it, she read it, and told him she could not perform it eight times a week without being destroyed.

So he made it a film.

He was told nobody wanted to see a crazy middle-aged dame. He mortgaged the house, borrowed from family, and took a very large loan from Peter Falk. A Woman Under the Influence premiered at the New York Film Festival in October 1974 to enormous acclaim and zero distribution offers.

Cassavetes distributed it himself, telephoning theater owners one by one. It grossed over $6 million against a budget of $1 million.

Rowlands won the Golden Globe and was nominated for the Academy Award. Cassavetes was nominated for Best Director in a field consisting of Coppola, Polanski, Fosse, and Truffaut. He lost to Coppola.

What followed was a run of pictures now regarded as his summit and seen at the time as evidence of a man losing his grip. The Killing of a Chinese Bookie was pulled from theaters after seven days. Opening Night played to nearly empty houses and was not picked up by an American distributor until 1991, two years after his death.

The money was gone. He wrote scripts for hire. When MGM asked whether he had anything suitable for child star Ricky Schroder, he produced a gangster chase called Gloria, which he described as “a very fast-moving, thoughtless piece about gangsters.”

Columbia bought it, wanted Rowlands, and insisted Cassavetes direct. Gloria came out in 1980 to the best reviews of his life and earned Rowlands a second Oscar nomination. It was the most warmly received film he ever made, and the one he believed in the least.

“There’s nothing I despise more than being entertained,” he said, and he meant it as a working principle.

In the spring of 1983, his mother died. That summer, he shot Love Streams for Cannon Films, playing a hollowed-out writer whose sister, played by Rowlands, arrives at his house with the wreckage of her own life and refuses to leave. He had asked journalist Michael Ventura to keep an on-set diary.

What Ventura observed and could not write at the time was that two or three weeks into the shoot, John was told he had six months to live.

Cassavetes said nothing. He simply began revising the film nightly, shooting in sequence, arguing the ending into new shapes. Everyone assumed he was rewriting because rewriting was what he did.

Ventura recorded the physical fact of it: the arms and legs going thin while the stomach swelled, “huge and tight as a drum.” Cassavetes would not wear a looser shirt. He decided that belly belonged to the character and let the camera have it.

Love Streams won the Golden Bear at Berlin in February 1984. His public position was not conciliatory. “I don’t give a damn what anybody says.

If you don’t have time to see it, don’t. If you don’t like it, don’t. If it doesn’t give you an answer, damn you.

I didn’t make it for you anyway.”

There was one more film and he hated it. In 1985, he stepped in to direct Big Trouble, a Double Indemnity spoof, as a favor to Peter Falk. Columbia vetoed his decisions and cut the film to suit itself.

Cassavetes’ verdict was pure bile. “I call it the aptly titled Big Trouble. If working on that comedy didn’t permanently 𝓀𝒾𝓁𝓁 my sense of humor, nothing will.”

It was not his final work, though almost nobody saw the thing that was. In May 1987 at the tiny Court Theatre in West Hollywood, with somewhere between 40 and 66 seats and around a dozen performances, he wrote and directed A Woman of Mystery, starring Rowlands as a homeless woman. Jonathan Rosenbaum called it Cassavetes’ last fully achieved work and one of the key theatrical experiences of his life.

There is no known recording.

The illness ran three and a half years in its acute phase. He had been diagnosed with cirrhosis and advised to stop drinking. He did not stop.

He had built an entire body of work out of people who cannot behave sensibly and cannot be talked out of themselves, and he was not going to make an exception for his own liver.

He kept writing. At his death, he left more than forty unproduced screenplays, several unproduced plays, and a novel version of Husbands running to 413 pages.

John Cassavetes died at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles on February 3rd, 1989, of complications of cirrhosis of the liver. He was 59. Gena Rowlands was at his side.

He is buried at Westwood Village Memorial Park, a few minutes’ walk from Marilyn Monroe, in a cemetery hidden behind office blocks off Wilshire Boulevard, which he would have found funny.

He had been nominated for Academy Awards as a writer, an actor, and a director, and had won nothing. He had made, on money scraped from parts he considered beneath him, a dozen films that no studio would have allowed to exist. The rehabilitation was total and very fast, as these things often are once the difficult man is safely underground.

Shadows, Faces, and A Woman Under the Influence are all in the National Film Registry. Every director who has ever maxed a credit card, borrowed a friend’s house, or stolen a shot is working in a tradition he more or less invented. Plenty of them, from Scorsese to the mumblecore generation, have said so out loud.

What survives is stranger and better than sainthood. He was, on the evidence, a con man, a bully, a magnificent charmer, and a terrible husband who somehow remained married for thirty-five years to a woman entirely his equal. Tom Noonan, who knew him, said most of the people who worship him would not have been able to stand being with him for an hour.

Rowlands, who stood him for decades, put it differently. “John was one of a kind, the most totally fearless person I’ve ever known.”

He never made a film about an exploding helicopter because he had never seen one. What he had seen was people destroying themselves in the smallest ways, hiding behind ideas and drink and hypocrisy. And he had, he admitted, done all of it himself.

That is the whole method and the whole John Cassavetes. He dared to fail, which he insisted was the artist’s only obligation, and he failed often, in public, expensively, and always on his own terms.